Island or reef? The legal question on the South China Sea formations

An international arbitration tribunal Tuesday upheld almost all of a claim by the Philippines against China's claim to a large swathe of the South China Sea.

At the heart of the matter was the question of whether the contested formations are true islands or mere reefs or shoals.

Islands, which must be capable of sustaining human settlement, extend the territorial rights of whichever nation they belong to into the surrounding waters, according to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea.

"China has internal waters, territorial sea and contiguous zone, based on Nanhai Zhudao," Beijing said in a statement carried by news agency Xinhua, using the name for all the islands in the zone.

But if they are reefs or shoals, submerged at high tide or otherwise uninhabitable, they cannot extend a nation's territory, and their status is determined by the proximity of the nearest nation within 200 nautical miles (340 kilometres).

In the case of the Spratly Islands and the Scarborough Shoal, which were the subject of Tuesday's ruling, that would put both within the Exclusive Ecoomic Zone of the Philippines.

The court found that the formations were not true islands, and that their status was therefore determined by their proximity of less than 200 nautical miles from the Philippines.

Last update: Tue, 12/07/2016 - 12:58

More from World

Syria accused of third chemical weapons attack

UN monitors have concluded that the Syrian regime used chlorine gas in a third chemical weapons attack last year,...

Yemen ceasefire expires as UN envoy pleads for extension

A three-day long truce in the Yemeni conflict expired at 11:59 pm local time (2059) GMT Saturday, despite a plea...

Venezuelan fighter intercepts Colombian passenger flight

A Colombian passenger plane was intercepted and escorted from Venezuelan airspace by a Venezuelan fighter plane, the...

AT&T agrees to buy Time Warner, reports say

Telecommunications giant AT&T has agreed to buy media conglomerate Time Warner in a deal worth 80 billion...

Aleppo ceasefire ends without promised evacuations

No civilians were evacuated during the Russian-announced truce in Aleppo, a Red Cross official in the city said...